35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (2024)

Special occasions call for only the best pie recipes. This collection of the most popular and best pie recipes will have you feeling giddy and excited for Christmas or the next holiday feast. Help yourself to the best pie recipes out there for special holiday occasions!

Best Pie Recipes To Get You In The Festive Mood!

I’m pretty positive everyone has a pie dish or recipe that reminds them of Christmas and other special occasions. Mine is Grammy’s special apple and pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving, and mom’s special lemon meringue pie for birthdays. For Christmas, it was a family tradition to prepare at least three different pie recipes, and I’m continuing the tradition. I’ve listed all the most liked and perfected best pie recipes online for more ideas. In the spirit of the holidays, I’m more than glad to share the best pie recipes with you.

1.Chocolate Peppermint Ganache Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (1)

This is a low-carb mint and chocolate ganache on top of a chocolatey, gluten-free cookie crust.With this chocolate pie,you’re going to enjoy the holiday without messing up your diet!

2.Cranberry Custard Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (2)

Imagine a buttery and flaky crust filled with a delightful custard and cranberry filling–that is what this cranberry custard pie is all about. Get creative with your raspberry pie, like topping it off with sugared cranberries, and you’ll have the best Christmas dessert ever!

3.Easy Eggnog Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (3)

Is it not Christmasy enough without eggnog, but in apie? Well, why not? Eggnog isversatile enough to incorporate into any holiday treat you want, just like thisdelectable eggnog pie.

4.Chocolate Mascarpone Raspberry Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (4)

If I will be serving a pie this Christmas, I want it to be extraordinary, and I think I already found The One!This pie recipesure takes holiday dessert to the next level!

5.Salted Caramel Apple Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (5)

Caramel and apple go hand in hand, that’s why this salted caramel apple pie makes the ideal pie you can prepare during the holiday season. I’m pretty sure this pie will quickly become a family favorite thanks to the heavenly smell of salted caramel.

6. Gingerbread Eggnog Pumpkin Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (6)

You may be going the rustic route with this gingerbread eggnog pumpkin pie, but you’re sure to have a very yummy treat to share with your family and friends on Christmas Day. After all, gingerbread, eggnog, and Christmas complement each other well.

7.Peppermint Crunch Ice Cream Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (7)

Oreo cookie pie crust goes well withpeppermint, chocolate fudge ice cream, and crushed candy canes in this ice cream pie recipe. Well, it’s always nice to have a delightful frozen treat to enjoy not only during Christmas, but any time of the year.

8. Apple Crumble Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (8)

If you love anything apple, thenthis is the pie for you. This apple crumb pie is filled with a delicious filling bursting with extreme apple goodness. And let’s not forget about the crumble topping!

Craving a sweet #Christmas treat? Learn how to make these rice krispies! https://t.co/Q8xu1lpDpq pic.twitter.com/E8icdiHEu4

— Homemade Recipes (@BestHomeRecipes) December 3, 2016

9.Dark Chocolate Salted Caramel Oreo Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (9)

No time? No problem! This no-bake chocolate pie could be the easiest pie to make during the holiday season with only five simple ingredients. Its three decadent layers will surely have you drooling!

10. Maple Pecan Pumpkin Pie

|

I love how simple this maple pecan pumpkin pie is but still looks festive at the same time. It’s pretty simple but puts you in a holiday mood.Andif you’re still on the hunt for the most delicious pumpkin recipe, your search might stop here!

11.French Silk Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (10)

This year, why not try a classic French silk pie recipe to please the crowd this holiday season? It’s quite different from your traditional Christmas pie but it’s guaranteed to make everyone go “Wow!”

12.Christmas Sugar Cookie Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (11)

Serving this pie made up of cookie dough, candy sprinkles, and assorted holiday candy on Christmas Day will make everybody–especially the kids—light up like Christmas morning!

13.Pear-Cranberry Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (12)

The beautiful pairingof pears and tangyred cranberries makes this pear-cranberry pie extremely attractive, festive, and delicious. I know you’re loving how it looks, so why not make this dreamy pie the focal point of your dinner table?

14. Brownie Pecan Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (13)

Your holiday treats aren’t complete without something pecan coupled with brownies on your list. This Christmas, don’t forget to makethis lovely brownie pecan pie recipe. It’s a nutty ooey gooey goodness, I promise you won’t regret!

15.Chocolate Chess Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (14)

This chocolate chess pieis a foolproof recipe that makes the perfect chocolatey and fudgy dessert for the holidays. It’s a mind-blowing pie that’s easy to makebut really hard to resist!

16. Red Velvet Cookie Pie Recipe

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (15)

Red is one of the colors of Christmas and as you all know about red–its the first color our eyes notice. If you want an eye-catching table for your guests, include this easy red velvet cookie pie recipe.

17. Best Coconut Cream Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (16)

Go for something tropical for a change these winter holidayfeasts. This coconut cream pie is definitely perfect with its snow-white cream and snowflake-like crumbs.

18. The Best Apple Pie Ever

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (17)

I’ll put my neck on the line here, but this apple pie recipe is the best indeed. It’s just as how Granny used to make it and taste just as such. If you want to start a Christmas apple pie tradition you can give this pie a try.

19. Four Berry Pie Recipe

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (18)

What makes a pie special is when you combine not just two, but four berries in one recipe. With strawberries, blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries in one, this is undeniably the pie for the party.

20. Chocolate And Peanut Butter Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (19)

For you who loves Oreos, peanut butter, and chocolate any time of the day, you’ll love this delightful pie recipe even for Christmas. Whip this up in a few minutes and impress your guests who equally love peanut butter and chocolate.

21. No-Bake Cream Cheese Peanut Butter Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (20)

You already have a lot on your hands this Christmas. You don’t have to skip preparing lots of desserts, but you can skip baking altogether with this no-bake pie. A special treat doesn’t have to mean hard labor all the time.

22. Buttermilk Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (21)

Get your fill of a classicbuttermilk pie popularly served on Thanksgiving and Christmas. It’s easy to make, calling for only a few ingredients, but the sumptuous taste is simply irresistible and unforgettable.

23. Best Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (22)

While this is a healthy pie you can enjoy year-round, if you love rhubarb, then this will make it to your Christmas or Thanksgiving party. You can also consider this for 4th of July. Whatever is the occasion, this fruity and naturally sweetened pie is perfect.

24. Triple Key Lime Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (23)

You may be reminded of the easy breezy beaches of the Florida Keys with key lime pies, but this triple layer key lime pie will practically take you there. Wouldn’t you want the promise of summer during the freezing winter holidays?

25. Chocolate Raspberry Cream Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (24)

Chocolate is perfect for any occasion, but a dark chocolate raspberry cream pie is definitely ideal for Christmas. Rich dark chocolate plus raspberries in a warm cream pie will surely warm you up in the cold of winter.

26. Raspberry Ribbon Pie Recipe

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (25)

“Every slice is a surprise”, is how I best describe the experience after enjoying this delicate raspberry ribbon pie recipe. It is truly amazing–it deserves a spot on my Christmas table.

27. Strawberries And Cream Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (26)

Don’t hold off on sweets this Christmas because this one is healthier with fresh fruit. If you like it rich, yet so light it literally melts in your mouth, you’ll love this strawberries and cream pie recipe.

28. Freezer Caramel Drizzle Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (27)

Special holiday dessert recipes almost always call for sweat and tears to make. Well, this freezer caramel drizzle pie is easy as pie– you can sleep on it!

29. Mississippi Mud Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (28)

This Mississippi mud pie will somewhat require your labor of love to prepare. Well, a decadent and rich chocolate pie recipe sure deserves your attention and a spot on a holiday feast table.

30. Best Ever Banana Pudding Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (29)

It’s hard not to eat when the occasion presents itself, especially at special ones like Christmas. Luckily, this banana pudding pie is rich in healthy banana for almost guilt-free pleasure.

31. Old Fashioned Lemon Icebox Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (30)

If you want something different from your usual lemon meringue pie, try this old-fashioned lemon icebox pie recipe. Now this one will really go through fire and ice to make. You bake the crust then freeze the pie–really worthy of a special occasion.

32. No-Bake Triple Layer Pumpkin Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (31)

This no-bake triple layer pumpkin pie will most likely make it my Thanksgiving menu, but it’s great for Christmas too. Well, whatever is the occasion, this special pie recipe is definitely worthy.

33. Candy Cane Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (32)

It’s a family tradition to serve at least three different pies every Christmas. This candy cane pie will make it to my menu for the kids but I won’t blame the adults if they love it too.

34. French Silk Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (33)

When you say silk, we know it’s delicate and soft, and so is this French silk pie. It’s in the chocolate and cream with a secret ingredient whipped up good to make the super creamy and delectable filling.

35. Millionaire Pie

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (34)

I saved the best for last and this millionaire pie recipe will totally make it to my Christmas menu. Not only does it looks so good, I’m positive the kids will love it with cherries in a fluffy and creamy filling.

Got room for one more? Check out this video to make a Christmas pork pie:

There you have it, foodies! The best pie recipes ever perfect for Christmas and other special holiday occasions. With this selection, I’m sure picking one for Christmas won’t be as easy as pie. I hope you enjoy this list and will try some of these best pie recipes!

Which of these best pie recipes are you planning to try for Christmas?Share your thoughts with us in the comments section below!

Up Next:26 Homemade Pie Recipes for Thanksgiving

Don’t forget to keep in touch, foodies!

Also, make sure to follow us onFacebook,Instagram,Pinterest, andTwitter!

Editor’s Note – This post was originally published in December 2016 and has been updated for quality and relevancy.

35 Best Pie Recipes Ever: Perfect For Christmas And Special Holidays (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dan Stracke

Last Updated:

Views: 5947

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dan Stracke

Birthday: 1992-08-25

Address: 2253 Brown Springs, East Alla, OH 38634-0309

Phone: +398735162064

Job: Investor Government Associate

Hobby: Shopping, LARPing, Scrapbooking, Surfing, Slacklining, Dance, Glassblowing

Introduction: My name is Dan Stracke, I am a homely, gleaming, glamorous, inquisitive, homely, gorgeous, light person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.